I used to work in a public library with a woman who didn’t read fiction. At all. Yet she was able to suggest book titles, new authors, titles-that-might-be-like-the-one-you-just-read to readers who wanted advice. She listened to reader’s feedback, kept up to date with reviews, and crucially, judged a book by its cover. Her book-enjoyment strike rate was pretty good.
I think her lack of experience actually helped. She didn’t have all the fears and doubts that plague those of us who read a lot.
This is what I imagine happened when someone asked her for advice on what to read next.
Reader: Hi. Can you suggest a book that I should read next?
Her: *thinks* Yes I can. Her: Sure. What kind of books do you like to read?
Reader: Um, well I read [TITLE] recently and really enjoyed it.
Her: *thinks* Everyone has read [TITLE] recently. Her: There are a lot of people reading that book! So you like [GENRE]?
Her: *thinks* [COVER] [COVER] [TITLE] [REVIEW]
Reader: Not usually. I don’t like [CHARACTERISTIC OF GENRE]. But I really enjoyed this one. Do you have any more like that?
Her: Yes, why don’t you try [TITLE]?
Reader: Thanks!
Her: You’re welcome! Come back and let me know what you think.
This is what happens when someone asks me for advice on what to read next…
Reader: Hi. Can you suggest a book that I should read next?
Me: *thinks* That’s a wide open field buddy. Me: Sure. What kind of books do you like to read?
Reader: Um, well I read [TITLE] recently and really enjoyed it.
Me: *thinks* Everyone has read [TITLE] recently. Me: There are a lot of people reading that book! So you like [GENRE]?
Me: *thinks* [TITLE] [TITLE] [TITLE] [AUTHOR] [AUTHOR]
Reader: Not usually. I don’t like [CHARACTERISTIC OF GENRE]. But I really enjoyed this one. Do you have any more like that?
Me: *thinks* oh god. Me: *says cheerfully* Probably! Was there anything about it that you really liked?
Me: *thinks* [TITLE] [TITLE] [AUTHOR] [AUTHOR] [SERIES]
Reader: I really liked the way it was written. I didn’t like the [DIFFERENT CHARACTERISTIC OF GENRE].
Me: *thinks* FUCK. Me: *says cheerfully* Okay, let me think about this.
Me: *thinks* [TITLE] That’s pretty heavy going. [TITLE] Teenage? Nah. [TITLE] Not in this weather! [AUTHOR] Mmm, risky. [TITLE] I LOVE this book!
Me: Well, you could try [TITLE]. It’s about [PLOT], is pretty [ADJECTIVE], much like [TITLE]…?
Reader: Oh. I was hoping for something more [DIFFERENT ADJECTIVE].
Me: *thinks* FUCK.Me: Oh, okay. Well try [TITLE] then.
Reader: Thanks!
Me: You’re welcome! Come back and let me know what you think.
Me: *is nibbled at by the mice of doubt for the rest of the day*